How to run a standalone blog, legally

What sort of hosting options do you have if you don't want to set up your blog with one of the big Chinese providers?

Last week, blogger Zousuper wrote about a discussion he had with the Shanghai Communications Administration about this question. The original site is currently inaccessible, but Ya, I Yee translated his chat log and subsequent analysis. Here's a pertinent excerpt:

The operator: "Our work is to conduct special certification, how can you individuals provide blog services?! Your blog has been shut down simply because you did not get a special certification before."
Zousuper: "My blog is personal blog, not forum or BSP, not open for register, only myself can publish articles..."

The operator: "That's not allowed! blogs and forum are the same, any blogs, forums, BBS, Chat are required to be examined by us, no one should open without our approve."
Zousuper: "If I register at your department, my blog can return to normal at once, right?"

The operator: "Not, it's now on the process of 'special renovation', our examine and approve work does not star yet, and according to your situation your blog will definitely not be approved. You are the person in charge of your blog, but you can't monitor the comments all the 24 hours."

William Long responded to Zousuper's post with a recommendations on how to maintain a legal personal blog on its own domain:

Survival for standalone blogs

by William Long

The necessary conditions for setting up a blog on a separate domain in China - whether or not it is illegal, whether or not it requires registration - is currently a hotly debated issue. From the look of current policy, it seems that all standalone websites that have interactive information have to be registered.

There are issues of location here. If the server is overseas, then theoretically speaking registration is not necessary, but there is no way to guarantee that the server's IP will be accessible. Rose Luqiu's 1510 Blogs is a typical example. When a large proportion of visitors are from the mainland, then under normal circumstances a mainland server will be chosen. This is when we arrive the question of the blog's legality.

Here I'll summarize the steps and conditions for legally setting up a blog on a standalone domain; this should be basically the same in all major cities across the country.

Website registration is not a simple question. MII registration is just a basic registration, suitable for non-forum websites that do not have interactive information. If you think that MII registration will solve everything, then you are very wrong. Of course, you could close the comments section to your blog and voluntarily choose not to disseminate "harmful information"; in that case the MII registration would be enough. If your website allows leaving messages and exchanging information, and its traffic is low, you may be able to simply get by. In general, for normal small websites, MII registration is enough.

If your website traffic is relatively large, particularly if it is highly interactive, like a forum or a blog, then you'll face the appearance of so-called "harmful information." Normally, when you discover "harmful information," someone will be tasked with notifying the webmaster to delete it; it becomes a problem when it occurs frequently.

Strictly speaking, individuals are not permitted to provide BBS services on the Internet (interactive online services in which users provide information for release, including message boards, electronic whiteboards, e-forums, online chat services, and guestbooks) without formally registering or passing review by state communication administrators. To providing interactive forum and guestbook services, you must set up "technological measures for network security," in addition to registering with the PSB's Internet Supervision Center. This means a system for review, control, and deletion of information, as well as associated "computer security personnel."

Usually, registering with the PSB Internet Supervision Center is pretty complicated and drawn-out. The registration is vastly different from MII's: it is very strict. If your website supports BBS, forums, guestbook, or chat services, then you must provide the following materials:

  1. A copy of the computer security personnel certificate;
  2. Registered Internet user network security form;
  3. Providers of Internet services for news, publishing, education, health, pharmaceuticals, and medical equipment must be approved by the appropriate government agencies in accordance with laws and regulations, and must present the government approval documents at the time of registration.

The computer security personnel certificate is typically obtained by paying 660 yuan to be trained and tested. That means that if you want to write a blog, you must first pass the "security worker" exam. The registration form basically requires writing out your name, ID#, home address, mobile phone number, and place of work, so that if there are any problems you can be arrested on the spot. If you do not provide this information, then your registration may not pass.

After you've registered, you then face the work of looking out for and cleaning up "harmful information" - this is the responsibility of the "computer security personnel." Because the appearance of "harmful information" on a forum or blog is ultimately the responsibility of the webmaster, the PSB will carry out punishment against the webmaster according to the volume of "harmful information" that is circulated. Here you'll run into the issue of standards for punishment. Current punishment standards takes into account the number of registered users, the quantity of circulating information, the hit count, and illegal revenue; so long as one area exceeds the standard then you're determined to be in "extremely serious circumstances." An article clicked by one person is completely different from the same article clicked by 10,000 people; are you able to guarantee 24-hour review for your personal blog or forum? If you cannot, then hiding your webpage counters and your pageview numbers may cut down on some unwanted trouble. At the same time, you should keep your website income a secret; there is nothing good and a whole lot bad about making your website's income public. Under normal circumstances, this is a standard for determining punishment. The greater your website's income, the more serious the problem, and the worse off you will be.

Hence, if you have a forum or a guestbook system, you've got a hidden time bomb. "Harmful information" will cause a lot of trouble for the webmaster when it surfaces. So if you have a forum, it's best to put it on a separate domain name and move it to an overseas server unless you can guarantee you'll be online 24 hours a day to prevent every single bit of "harmful information" from being published. Otherwise you're giving them an angle to get you.. So high-risk systems like forums should be moved out. The same goes for guestbooks and comments to blog posts. If you cannot cut off comment functions, then you must implement keyword filters to turn every sensitive word into ××. Doing this will save you a bit of unnecessary trouble.

In short, there is currently no clear idea about the system for registering blogs, but for most blogs that have a fair number of comments and discussion, it's no good to simply register with MII; you have to go to the local PSB's website to register for it to have any effect. And you must maintain a good relationship with the local PSB. Whatever they want, you give it to them; don't antagonize them, and don't dispute matters of theory with them. Don't say anything when it's not your turn - it won't work, anyway.

Links and Sources
There are currently 5 Comments for How to run a standalone blog, legally.

Comments on How to run a standalone blog, legally

Yeah it sucks, I'm thinking about opening up maybe an English blog to talk about my views of things going on in China and world, but I don't really know how.

Any suggestions where should I go? Hey, you guys provide blog space?

It shouldn't amaze me yet it never ceases to do so - how can the Chinese people stand for this kind of mal-treatment. No freedom of expression... it would drive me mad! I recently sent a book to a friend of mine in China and this is a book that she could easily purchase herself in China, but probably just because it is religious in nature - she hasn't recieved 1.5 months later. How can they call it Renmin Gonghe Guo? It should be called nuli gongheguo

Peter: It wouldn't change any thing by indignation alone or calling it bad names, would it? To truely understand the situation, the real question lies not in "how can", but "why".

Imagine you were born and brought up in knee-high of a certain propaganda, before long you grew numb, part of you basic instinct was suppressed, you take it for granted and never feel about it again, similar to what entertainment business done to Amercians. Of course not everyone is sedated, which leads to the second question: How?

Any systems that's been established for so long cannot be easily overthrown overnight. Look what happened in iraq, democracy and freedom of speech, as good as they are, cannot be rushed, let alone be thrust upon. And don't forget, China is a country in its 3000 years of civilization has never seen the light of individualism, and in the last 150 years has gone through hell, wars after wars, in battle fields and in people's minds. Look at 9/11, only the first(second?) real attack on the US soil, see what it did to your country, the panic, shedding of the US Constituion, control of the media, death of habeas corpus, Patriot Act...I'd say America is moving just toward where we are.

What I'm saying is that the easy anwser is not always the right anwser. Personally I think it's a bit paranoia to think Chinese government is behind the delay of your friend's book, be it religious or not, but it's understandable for an foreigner who detests an Authoritarian state to think that way.

I love mangoes, the fruit

Is this harmful ?

in 1968, mango was a great fruit to eat.

link and link

today seems that if you want to run a blog, you need to eat a lot of mangoes.

I know all these things - and I agree - but I certainly wouldn't agree with your characterization of the situation in the US. Since the 1980's the hope for change from the bottom up just seems to have been completely wiped out. I guess this is one reason why so few Chinese students in the US ever go back to China. That said - I try to remain hopeful that the current Chinese leadership won't cause WWIII and that there will be a bright future for China where freedom of expression is not viewed as a threat. I hope this day comes in my life time. How amazing it would be!

China Media Timeline
Major media events over the last three decades
Danwei Model Workers
The latest recommended blogs and new media
From 2008
Front Page of the Day
A different newspaper every weekday
From the Vault
Classic Danwei posts
+ Culture and corporate propaganda in Soho Xiaobao (2007.11): Mid-2007 issues of Soho Xiaobao (SOHO小报), illustrating the complicated identity of in-house magazines run by real estate companies.
+ Internet executives complain about excessive Net censorship (2010.03): Internet executives complain about excessive Net censorship at an officially sanctioned meeting in Shenzhen.
+ Crowd-sourced cheating on the 2010 gaokao (2010.06): A student in Sichuan seeks help with the ancient Chinese section of this year's college entrance exam -- while the test is going on!
Danwei Archives