|
Business
Mattel apologizes to ChinaPosted by Jeremy Goldkorn, September 22, 2007 2:59 PM
However, the apology from Mattel's CEO Bob Eckert to American parents on Mattel's website makes no mention of any such design flaws.
There are currently 8 Comments for Mattel apologizes to China.
Comments on Mattel apologizes to ChinaI wonder when did Mattel's toy specs ever include lead paint? Pre- 1930s? what's really funny is the comments of this news. Maybe they can send us something with asbestos next. What a crock of crap! hey, nanheyangrouchuan & hairy carrot: I gather that eating-crow & apologizing are not to your taste? Even where Mattel/you, is/are wrong? Says a lot about the worth of your comments, I guess. Have you heard of Ben "SPEAK, THAT I MAY KNOW THEE" Johnson? Probably not. Nanhe, your comment is off base. Whatever the political backstory behind the apology, the facts it references are true: the vast majority of the 19 million Mattel toys recalled resulted from design flaws of Mattel's (e.g the small magnets that could come unattached), not manufacturing flaws by Chinese factories. The lead paint affected only 400,000 of the total recall; in overall toy sales this is a small number. Not to say there is not a quality issue with Chinese manufacturing, but this issue has been blown way out of proportion by the U.S. media and politicians eager to look tough. I haven't seen any evidence to suggest that quality is a bigger problem in China than in other manufacturing countries such as India, Mexico, Indonesia, etc. off base comments by me? bah mantou! "Whatever the political backstory behind the apology, the facts it references are true: the vast majority of the 19 million Mattel toys recalled resulted from design flaws of Mattel's (e.g the small magnets that could come unattached), not manufacturing flaws by Chinese factories" Ever heard of flaws in the material composition? Cutting corners in that realm can allow the magnets to break off very easily. Oh yeah, Chinese companies never cut corners in materials manufacturing (besides cars, concrete, chemical processing, etc). It's completely obvious why Mattel "apologized"...because they want to continue to make cheap toys and because in the future they want to sell them in China...its a temporary pain for a future gain. It's similar to Google and the like compromising their principles to operate in the "world's hottest economy". Take this apology with a grain of salt folks Does anyone have the full transcript of what Thomas Debrowski said? It's hard to tell whether Mattel went overboard in its apology without seeing the full text. Certainly Mattel was right to apologize for the fact that its design flaws contributed to the damage to the reputation of Chinese goods. But the apology seems to have gone too far in accepting total responsibility for the problems, when there is obviously a serious problem with business ethics and trust in China. |
Jobs in China
Recent Comments
Thomas Cra on
What Robert Scoble learned in China
Bill on
Who cares about maps?
bocaj on
CCTV rakes in big ad money
Thomas Cra on
Con artist engineers demolition of government offices
Micah Sitt on
Yellow fever
Shaan on
The body in the lake
Danwei.TV
Danwei Model Workers
![]() Recommended blogs and new media
China Media Timeline
Major media events over the last three decades
Books on China
To die poor is a sin: An excerpt of Factory Girls by Leslie T. Chang.
In Wang Shuo's No Man's Land: Geremie Barme addresses Wang Shuo's 千万别把我当人.
Swimming with Mao, a memoir essay: This memoir piece is by Xujun Eberlein, author of the new short story book Apologies Forthcoming'.
Front Page of the Day
A different newspaper every weekday
From the Vault
Classic Danwei posts
+ People: Dirk Eschenbacher, Ogilvy One (2004.06): Dirk Eschenbacher is Ogilvy One's Regional Creative Director for Asia Pacific, in charge of all interactive creative in the world's fastest-growing online marketing environment. Originally from Munich, he has been in Asia for six years. After living in Thailand for three years running his own web design studio, he moved to Beijing to join Ogilvy One. + Anatomy of a bogus drug ad (2005.05): When I opened my paper yesterday evening, I discovered a garish four-page insert from a company called Warner advertising a product called "Shark" 帅克. My suspicions were aroused by the unnumbered pages and curious celebrity endorsements, and a quick survey of other news kiosks confirmed that this ad did not come from the Mirror distribution center. + Lip-Service: Lip-Synching in Chinese Pop Music by David Moser (2005.03): When we showed up at the studio for the taping, we discovered that there was no microphone for our singer, no recording equipment or hookups for our amplifiers, and not even any electrical outlets on the stage. "How are we supposed to do our number?" I asked the studio crew. They looked at us incredulously. "You actually want to sing the song live?" they said
Danwei Archives
Danwei Feeds
Via Feedsky
or Feedburner |


