Net Nanny Follies

Would you consider leaving China because of Internet blocks?

Prompted by a blogpost on Chinasolved.com about 'China fractured web', I put together a short online survey and advertised it on my personal Twitter feed yesterday afternoon. It was also mentioned on Danwei's Twitter feed and on Flypig's feed.

By this morning, there were 100 responses. The results are below.

Bear in mind that everyone who responded is almost certainly a heavy Twitter user, and part of the Internet-addicted crowd of people that read Danwei and use Twitter in China despite the blocks on both sites.

The results are therefore hardly representative of anything but Danwei readers and my own circle of Net buddies, who are all juiced up on broadband.

Interestingly, The ratio of Chinese to foreign respondents is consistent with every previous survey we've done about Danwei's readers: around 70% Westerners to 30% Chinese.

1. Do China's Internet blocks make your work difficult?
Yes: 84
No: 16

2. Do China's Internet blocks make your personal life difficult or entertainment difficult to access?
Yes: 90
No: 10

3. Would you consider leaving China because of Internet blocks?
Yes: 60
No: 40

4. Are you a Mainlander, from Hong Kong, Macao or Taiwan, or a foreigner?
Mainlander: 27
HK / Taiwan, Macao: 3
Foreigner: 70

Comments
These are some of the comments respondents left:

If you rely on the internet that much, then you really need a life. When in Rome...

Use a secure proxy and tunnel your traffic!

At this stage I wouldn't leave based on this but if things get worse then I may well leave.

Internet blocks suck ass, but if the only reason why you're here is because of China's reputation for world-class high-speed Internet, and now you're disappointed, you're a moron. If you're here for something else, you can work around the annoying blocks.

GFW drives me crazy!

我会翻墙!

I'm writing as someone who lived in China for quite a long time before moving away for reasons unconnected to blocking. The blocking is not enough, I think, to make someone who is already there want to leave, but it certainly does make it less likely that I would want to return.

Is anybody really going to leave China because it takes a VPN to Twitter?

to me it shows fear and weakness on the part of the government .. i worry for them

Getting very f***ed off with the not so Great Firewall of China

Fuck GFW and long live the network

Goldkorn, you're a douchebag

Internet blocks alone wouldn't cause me to leave, but could push me over the edge in conjunction with something else like visa hassles.

Fuck GFW

As Chinese born American living in Beijing, Internet blocks doesn't make my work life any more difficult, just the personal communication and entertaining part of the life such as Facebook I use to keep touch with my friends. Not a big deal. Thu, Aug 20, 2009 3:24

Would be interesting if the survey could factor in results over time. Any new foreigner in China will probably answer yes to 1 and 2, but the longer you stay, the more you can find ways around for number 2. As an ESL teacher, I need Youtube and Google Images for lessons, so full and partial blocks disrupt my work. Anyways, maybe add a question #6 to ask how long the person has lived here.

SSH tunnel

I assume things will get better after the 60th anniversary festivities are done with, but who really knows?

没钱,怎么离开?

This is one of the biggest reasons I don't think I will move to China for the long-term. It's not just the blocks themselves but what they stand for.

I wouldn't leave China only because of blocks, but they are a contributing factor in my desire to eventually leave – more because they reflect the condescending attitude of the government toward its citizens than because I can't get to any particular website.

Free YouTube, free Facebook

I've considered a move to Hong Kong, but not seriously. Not yet.

Already left China because of this reason.

The blocks are very easy to get around and make virtually no difference.

There are currently 4 Comments for Would you consider leaving China because of Internet blocks?.

Comments on Would you consider leaving China because of Internet blocks?

I think the big moment comes in the weeks after October 1. We'll find out then if all the blocking has merely been to keep things all nice and fluffy in the build up to the 60th anniversary, or whether it is a far more concerted, long-term effort to control the conversation online.

Fingers crossed its the former - if not, time to starting thinking up ways to hit back.

I lived in China for almost 5 years and finally decided to leave last year... combination of changing government regulations and internet blocks.

Must say it was a wise decision, glad to leave China

Most of my favorite internet connections were blocked. it drived me crazy. it's the fact. and i had tried a lot of ways to log in . sometimes it works. but i admit GFW is so powerful. Meanwhile i failed to try.

GFW is NOT that powerful, USD 5 a month can just make us get through it. StrongVPN, FBVPN, both work,and FBVPN even support all my handhold devices, like iPhone and android.

China Media Timeline
Major media events over the last three decades
Danwei Model Workers
The latest recommended blogs and new media
laomo2010x80.jpg
From 2008
Front Page of the Day
A different newspaper every weekday
From the Vault
Classic Danwei posts
+ Culture and corporate propaganda in Soho Xiaobao (2007.11): Mid-2007 issues of Soho Xiaobao (SOHO小报), illustrating the complicated identity of in-house magazines run by real estate companies.
+ Internet executives complain about excessive Net censorship (2010.03): Internet executives complain about excessive Net censorship at an officially sanctioned meeting in Shenzhen.
+ Crowd-sourced cheating on the 2010 gaokao (2010.06): A student in Sichuan seeks help with the ancient Chinese section of this year's college entrance exam -- while the test is going on!
Danwei Archives