Translation

Malformed English in Guiyang delights online commenters

JDM080507guiyang.jpg
The sun's expensive in Guiyang

This entertaining sign was posted by the Guiyang Passenger Railway Branch and was recently discovered by the Chengdu Business News.

Although the English translation of the first line, "The expensive sun multiplies by a duty a police to pay a brigade," is completely incomprehensible, there's no mystery as to how it occurred: it's basically a character-by-character translation of 贵阳乘警支队:

The expensive () sun () multiplies () by a duty (??) a police () to pay () a brigade ().

What it should be: Guiyang (贵阳) Rail Police (乘警) Detachment (支队). Whoever reviewed the translation didn't even notice that it should have contained the name of the city.

The second line is more confusing. It's actually a hotline for reporting police behavior (警风) and road conditions (路风), where , "breeze," also carries the meaning "style" or "behavior" (as in the jargon term 党风, "working style of the party"). So that explains the first three words of the translation.

But the next few words make no sense at all. How did "the hurl" and "tell" come out of 监督, "to supervise"? Even when broken into individual characters, the meaning's just not there. Fortunately, the final word, 电话, "telephone," is rendered correctly.

Chengdu Business News spoke to an expert who said that even a middle school student wouldn't have come up with such an absurd translation. He speculated that the translator must have used the most primitive version of Chinese-English translation software available.

Commenters posting on Netease had a field day with the article. The current top comment offers other creative translations for Chinese cities (there are many more here:

北京——North Capital
武汉——Fight Man
青岛——Green Island
四川——Four Mountains
宝鸡——Expensive Chicken
天津——Sky Ferry
海口——Sea Mouth
长沙——Long Sand
上海——Above Sea
长春——Long Spring
兰州——Blue State

The Guiyang Rail Passenger Branch, which falls under the authority of the Chengdu Railway Bureau, has promised to fix the sign as soon as possible.

Links and Sources
 
There are currently 13 Comments for Malformed English in Guiyang delights online commenters.

Comments on Malformed English in Guiyang delights online commenters

watch out, in IE6, this post has a formatting error that gives subsequent posts a dotted underline.

推荐金老师看看这篇文章,关于中国学术期刊用fu*k的博客分析。link

Thanks, Inst. It's fixed now.

I'm not even Chinese, and I can tell that
"四川——Four Mountains" is incorrect.

The translation should be "4 rivers"?

@steve

Yes, you are right.

川, as its glyph shows, is flowing water (cough, not from water faucet).

Would the author of the article like to correct his own spelling of "occurred"?

[Maybe. --JM]

And 兰州 means "orchid state". 兰 appears to have been confused with the homophonous 蓝 "blue".

兰 can be used in place of 蓝 when refering to "blue color". This is a widely accepted misuse.

Orchid, in English, can be also used as color, light purple.

hurl + tell = 投訴

They should learn to use google language tools. It gives pretty accurate translation from chinese to english now.

I'm surprised nobody has posted a creative translation of Anhui's provincial capital (Hefei).

Hefei (合肥) is translated further down in the Netease thread as "two fat."

"Two fat" is derived from a cross talk about place names, hehe.

Post a comment

All comments are moderated and subject to review by Danwei contributors and editors, but well-grounded and articulate comments will be published regardless of which way they lean. Because comments published on any website ultimately contribute to the character of that website, we may decline to publish comments that are irrelevant, redundant, or that do not adhere to generally accepted standards of courtesy; if you are looking for a fight, there are plenty of other venues available online.


Some useful html: <b>bold</b>, <i>italic</i>,
<a href="http://www.danwei.org">link</a>

Corruption