|
Trends and Buzz
Beijing cleans up its sign translationsPosted by Joel Martinsen, September 6, 2005 6:29 PM
![]() Sign for Beijing's famous Racist Park. As part of its campaign to prepare the city for an influx of foreign visitors attending the Olympic Games, Beijing is in the process of correcting and standardizing translations on signs across the city. Beijing began turning its attention to multilingual signs as part of the "reform and opening up" in the 80s, especially in preparation for the 1990 Asian Games. Latin characters are certainly more familiar to most foreign visitors than hanzi, but translations vary from serviceable to eyebrow-raising to completely incomprehensible. To avoid embarrassment come 2008, the city is overhauling the signs, and in early August it set up a website for city residents to point out areas that needed attention. The media got into the act: for a week or so in August, Beijing's Legal Mirror published a "mistake of the day" photograph. Beijing's translated signs exhibit several types of problems:
These examples were taken from the website of the "Beijing Speaks to the World" campaign. A significant number of submissions do point out mistakes, and many offer corrections. A sizeable minority, however, seem to want to exchange one mistake for another - is "No Service Now" any better than "Business Suspended" as a translation of 暂停营业? In addition to the genuine errors mentioned here, there seems to be a feeling that even faultless English translations are in many cases too abrupt or commanding, not "harmonious" enough (to borrow the current political buzzword). Not content with changing "Stop to smoke" into "No Smoking," many feel that Beijing should follow the "*-free" phrasing that is trendy in many places, and change all "No Smoking" signs over to "Smoke-Free Building," "Smoke-Free Library" and such. Questions of style do not occur merely on English signage, however. Beijing recently turned down a proposal to change the names of scores of bus stops across the city that include "grave" 坟 in their names; people felt these names were too morbid and wanted them changed to either the more cultured "mausoleum" 陵 or one of several sound-alikes. The proposal was felt to be too much of a hassle, as well as a rejection of Beijing's history, so it was eventually rejected. ![]() One other aspect of public English that has received attention lately has been the proliferation of trendy real-estate developments that are known primarily by an English name. Ads in local papers for new communities use English names and slogans in their ad copy (sometimes miswritten). Older residents complain that they don't know their city anymore. Here we see a developer pushing the boundaries just a bit more - the development here isn't given a name in English, or in any other foreign language for that matter. An unpronounceable string of IPA symbols seems to want to be read as "Art by Shore," but I couldn't tell you if that's what it's really intended to mean. Pity the poor Beijing taxi driver who has to read that off of a "Please take me to _____" card. Links and Sources
|
Jobs in China
Recent Comments
David Ever on
CCTV underpants and hemorrhoids in the Shanghai press
banyue on
Linda Jaivin on Sexy Beijing
David D on
Subway trains to shelter Sichuan homeless
xiaowang on
Blogger Conference interviews: Ping Ke
Danwei.TV
Danwei Model Workers
![]() Recommended blogs and new media
China Media Timeline
Major media events over the last three decades
Books on China
A brief history of Shanghai's future: An essay by Jeffrey Wasserstrom, author of Global Shanghai, 1850-2010.
Carl Crow's 400 Million Customers: An excerpt from Carl Crow's classic 400 Million Customers and an introduction by Paul French.
Tom Carter: Portrait of a People: Tom Carter is a photographer who spent two years backpacking around China, taking photographs of people in every province. The result is a book called China: Portrait of a People, recently published by Blacksmith Books.
Front Page of the Day
A different newspaper every weekday
From the Vault
Classic Danwei posts
+ How much money does a Beijing lawyer make? (2005.06): Today's edition of the Legal Mirror (法制晚报) featured a new financial column called 'Checking Your Pockets' (钱包大兜底). The aim of the column is to inform the readers about how much money people in selected industries make in Beijing. To pay respect to its name, Legal Mirror kicked off with lawyers. Here are the results of the report: + Paper tigers, whispering sweet nothings into each other's ears (2008.02): An article originally published in 1999 by Geremie Barmé about newspapers in China and how they have changed since the Cultural Revolution. + SARFT uncovers a poisoned apple (2007.03): Chang Ping (长平) on SARFT's criticism of Lost in Beijing (苹果 aka Apple), Still Life (三峡好人), and Thirteen Princess Trees (十三棵泡桐).
Danwei Archives
Danwei Feeds
Via Feedsky
or Feedburner |




